Public rubric
Sharp at Home
Every learner is graded on these lines. Pass mark 70 of 100. Any change to a single character changes the fingerprint.
Rubric v1, fingerprint ada2 1f9f be03
Or check it yourself: the fingerprint is the first 12 characters of the SHA-256 of this file (shasum -a 256 rubric-v1.json). Bought already? Verify your order on PayPal. Or change one line and check again against a real order.
Check a grade receipt
Open or paste the JSON a learner downloaded from their grade receipt. It matches only if nothing in it was edited and every grade in it is still the one on file.
Question 1, 25 points
Priya hones her chef's knife with a steel every Sunday, yet right after honing it still squashes tomatoes. Her brother says to hone it for longer. Explain what honing does, what is really wrong with her knife, and what she should do.
- 7 ptsSays honing pushes a rolled edge back into line
- 7 ptsSays honing removes almost no metal, so it can't rebuild a worn edge
- 11 ptsSays Priya's edge is worn and the knife needs sharpening on a stone
- max 10The answer tells Priya that honing more or honing for longer is the fix
Question 2, 25 points
Tomas owns a Western chef's knife and a new 1000-grit water stone, and he has never sharpened before. List what he must do to get ready before his first sharpening stroke, and how he checks that he has the angle right.
- 7 ptsSoaks the stone until the bubbles stop, about ten minutes. Saying only to soak it, with no sign of when it is ready, is partial
- 5 ptsPuts a damp towel under the stone so it can't slide. Mentioning a towel with neither the damp cloth nor the reason is partial
- 7 ptsUses an angle of 20 degrees per side for a Western chef's knife
- 6 ptsChecks the angle by colouring the bevel with a marker and seeing where the ink comes off after a light stroke
Question 3, 25 points
Lena has been sharpening one side of her knife for ten minutes and isn't sure when to flip it over. Tell her how to know when to flip, and what she does to finish the knife once both sides are done.
- 9 ptsSays to feel for a burr on the opposite side of the edge
- 7 ptsSays the burr must run the whole length of the edge, heel to tip, before she flips
- 9 ptsSays to finish by removing the burr with light alternating strokes or by stropping
- max 12The answer tells Lena to decide by a set number of strokes or a set amount of time
Question 4, 25 points
Sam's knife goes dull within a month. He cuts on a glass board and runs the knife through the dishwasher. Say what is damaging the edge, and give him a routine that keeps it sharp.
- 7 ptsSays to stop cutting on glass and use a wood or plastic board
- 6 ptsSays to keep the knife out of the dishwasher and wash it by hand
- 6 ptsSays to hone about once a week
- 6 ptsSays to sharpen on the stone about every three months